A hospital must pay the attorneys’ fees of a medical-malpractice plaintiff after defense counsel’s improper closing argument caused a mistrial, a Superior Court judge has ruled.
The plaintiff argued that a fee award was appropriate because the defendant’s comments about the plaintiff’s expert witness during the closing amounted to an attempt to present an “anything is possible” causation theory that the judge had already prohibited.
Presiding Judge Alice B. Gibney agreed.
“[T]his case presents unique and different circumstances from those involving mere improper statements during a closing argument,” Gibney said. “Accordingly, this Court equitably fashions a remedy that requires Defendant to reimburse Plaintiffs for attorneys’ fees and costs related to [the expert]’s appearance at the first trial.”
The 14-page decision is Vann v. Women and Infants Hospital, Lawyers Weekly No. 61-174-10. The full text of the ruling can be found by clicking here.
Providence attorneys Miriam Weizenbaum and Amato A. DeLuca represented the plaintiff. Michael G. Sarli of Providence represented the defendant.
Search Closing Argument
- 1st Circuit rules in favor of gay marriage in Puerto Rico case
- Attorney General Peter Kilmartin to Recognize National Crime Victims’ Rights Week with Victims’ Grove Ceremony
- Photo ID Required – Rhode Island Primary Elections 2014
- Chicago Pizza, RICO and the Politics of Development
- Court Denies Motion to add Cities and Towns to Rhode Island State Pension Lawsuit
- Rhode Islander sues Cristiano Ronaldo over CR7
- RI Hispanic Bar Association Meet and Greet
- Federal Court: Warwick City Worker Prohibited from US Senate run
- Supreme Court decides Whistleblower Case in Rhode Island
- Statute of Limitations for Underpayment of TDI Benefits
Blog CloudAttorney General Closing Arguments Congressional District 1 Constitutional Law Criminal Law Culture Elections Law Ethics First Circuit Gratuitous Self Promotion health care Housing MA Courts MA Politics Marriage Equality medical malpractice Modern Culture National Civil Rights National Courts National Economy National Politics RI Courts RI Crime RI Politics SCORI SCOTUS Technology Trial Strategies Uncategorized Workers Rights