Judge Gibney Passes a Medical Negligence Case During Closing Arguments

In a move that surprised a packed courtroom, Superior Court Judge Alice Gibney today passed (aka declared a mistrial) the case of Vann v. Women & Infants Hospital after a five-week medical negligence trial and between defendant’s closing argument and plaintiff’s closing argument.

Gidley, Sarli and Marusak represented the defendant hospital and DeLuca and Weizenbaum (disclosure: where I work) represented the plaintiff child.  The plaintiff alleged that employees of the defendant hospital used excessive force in attempting to resolve a shoulder dystocia (a stuck shoulder) during the birth of the plaintiff in 2000, causing severe and permanent nerve damage to the boy’s right arm such that he has virtually no function of his right arm.

Judge Gibney decided to pass the case after finding the actions of defense counsel, Michael G. Sarli, in closing argument to be “disingenuous” when he argued to the jury a theory of causation that the judge explicitly excluded during the trial.  She said that his argument was prejudicial to the plaintiff.  In addition, she also said that it would be prejudicial to the defendant if she were to read a curative jury instruction to the jury.  The Court did not elaborate on the latter point.

Advertisements

4 responses to “Judge Gibney Passes a Medical Negligence Case During Closing Arguments

  1. Presumably this was on the Plaintiff’s motion?

  2. No. Passing the case was not upon the Plaintiff’s motion. The Plaintiff had moved for a curative jury instruction. The Court, however, said that a jury instruction would be prejudicial to the defendant. Judge Gibney then stated that she was passing the case.

  3. Wow!

    Don’t think I’ve ever seen a sua sponte mistrial in a civil case.

  4. Pingback: Defendant Hospital Ordered to Costs & Attorneys’ Fees after Improper Closing Argument | Closing Argument: a blog on truth, justice, the law (and the politics in between)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s